The Scammers’ Ledger: Insights Into Mail Fraud From Criminal Records | Ep. 1

Welcome to the premiere episode of The Scammers’ Ledger, part of Storymagzine.com’s True Crime Podcast series! Hosts Max and Lena uncover a chilling truth: over 1.3 million people fell victim to mail fraud, with older adults hit hardest. Using data straight from the scammers’ own databases – seized by the U.S. Postal Inspection Service – this episode reveals how these criminals operated and who they targeted. Watch the full podcast below, then dive into the key insights and transcript to explore the story behind the stats.

Key Insights From Episode 1

Dive into the chilling data behind our first episode, sourced from the National Institute of Justice (NIJ) study of scammers’ own records:

• Massive Fraud Network: Over 1.38 million victims and 11.87 million incidents tracked across 1999-2018—the biggest mail fraud analysis ever.
• Older Adults Targeted: 57% of victims were over 60, with 32% over 70, making seniors the top targets.
• Huge Losses for the Elderly: Those in their 80s lost 30% of the total cash despite being just 15% of victims.
• Repeat Victims Fuel Profits: 62% faced multiple scams (average: 9 times), with the worst cases losing $1,771 each—62% of the $216 million total.
• Age Drives Risk: Victims in their 70s and 80s were 9% more likely to be re-scammed; 18-29-year-olds were 24% less likely.
• Scammers’ Speed: Repeat scams hit every 20 days for the hardest-hit, down from 201 days initially.
• Seasonal Spikes: March saw 17% more fraud than average; November dropped 11% below.
• Old-School Payments: 54% of one scam’s payments were checks—mail fraud’s vintage roots run deep.

These stats reveal a predatory system targeting the vulnerable. Source: National Institute of Justice

Full Transcript

Below is the full script from Max and Lena’s deep dive. Read along or revisit your favorite moments!

Max: Picture this: a database with your name, your age, and every dollar you’ve lost—not to a bank, not to a friend, but to a criminal. Now imagine that database in the hands of the people who scammed you. That’s not a what-if. That’s real.

Lena: Wait, Max, you’re saying scammers actually keep records of this stuff? Like, spreadsheets of who they’ve ripped off?

Max: Exactly, Lena. And in this episode, we’re cracking those records wide open—seized by the feds, exposing over a million victims of mail fraud across nearly two decades. The biggest target? Older adults—people like your grandparents, your neighbors, maybe even us one day.

Lena: Okay, I’m already creeped out. This sounds like a horror movie, not a crime story.

Max: It’s worse than that. Welcome to The Scammers’ Ledger, where we dig into the dark corners of crime with cold, hard data. I’m Max.

Lena: And I’m Lena. Let’s unlock this ledger—whatever that means—and figure out what’s going on.

Max: Most of us think of fraud as a phone call from a fake prince or a sketchy email. But this? This is mail fraud—old-school envelopes stuffed with lies, landing in mailboxes across America. And the scammers behind it? They didn’t just wing it. They kept records. Detailed, digital records, like a twisted version of the software your favorite store uses to track your shopping habits.

Lena: So, what, they’re like the Amazon of crime? Tracking their ‘customers’?

Max: Pretty much. Sweepstakes promising millions if you just send a small fee. Lotteries you never entered. Psychics claiming they can fix your life—for a price. These weren’t one-off cons. They were operations, raking in cash from 1999 to 2018.

Lena: Psychics? Seriously? Who’s falling for that in the 2000s?

Max: You’d be surprised. And here’s how we know: the U.S. Postal Inspection Service busted four of these scams and seized their databases. Then the National Institute of Justice funded researchers at RTI International to analyze it all—1.3 million victims, 11.8 million individual fraud incidents.

Lena: Hold up—11.8 million? That’s not a scam, that’s an industry!

Max: It is. This isn’t just a study—it’s the largest analysis of repeat mass marketing fraud ever. And it’s not based on shaky victim memories. It’s straight from the criminals’ ledgers.

Lena: Okay, I’m sold. What’s in these ledgers? Who’s getting hit?

Max: Two scams lured people with fake sweepstakes and lotteries—‘You’ve won a million bucks! Just send $20 to claim it.’ The other two peddled psychic readings—‘Pay me, and I’ll tell your future.’ Each one tracked their victims like a business tracks customers. Names, ages, how much they paid, how often. And when the researchers stitched these four databases together, they uncovered a story bigger than anyone expected.

Max: Here’s where it gets real. Who were these victims? You might think fraud hits everyone equally—young, old, rich, poor. But the data says otherwise. The average age when they first got scammed? 61 years old.

Lena: 61? That’s… my parents’ age. That’s not even that old!

Max: Right? Most of them—57%—were already in their 60s when the scammers sank their hooks in. Nearly a third—32%—were over 70. We’re talking people who’ve worked their whole lives, retired, settled down… and then this.

Lena: That’s messed up. But why them? Are they just easier targets?

Max: That’s the question. It’s not just that older adults were targeted—it’s how much they lost. People in their 70s and 80s didn’t just get hit once—they got hit more often and harder. They suffered 9% more repeat scams compared to folks in their 50s. The youngest victims—18 to 29? They were 24% less likely to get scammed again.

Lena: So the young ones dodge the bullet, but the older you get, the worse it gets?

Max: Exactly. And the money? Losses peaked in the 80s age group. They made up less than 15% of the victims but accounted for nearly 30% of all the cash these scammers pocketed.

Lena: 30% from 15%? That’s insane. What’s that look like in real life?

Max: Picture someone in their 80s, maybe living alone, opening their mail. A letter says they’ve won big or a psychic promises hope. They send $20, $50, $100. Then another letter comes. And another. Before they know it, they’re in deep. The researchers found older adults were even more likely to get scammed by multiple operations—like their names were being traded between criminals.

Lena: Traded? Like they’re passing around a hit list? That’s dark.

Max: It is. The data doesn’t say if they’re getting more scam letters than younger folks. But you’ve got to wonder: are they more trusting? More desperate for connection? Or are scammers just that good at picking their marks?

Lena: I’m betting on the scammers being pros. They’ve got this down to a science.

Max: Now let’s talk about the repeat game. 62% of these victims—over half—didn’t get scammed just once. They got hit again and again, averaging nine incidents each. Nine times they sent money to a lie.

Lena: Nine times? How do you fall for it nine times?

Max: That’s what I asked. But for some, it went way beyond that. The worst cases—people scammed over 20 times—were less than 1 in 10 victims. But their losses? An average of $1,771 per person. That’s $216 million total—62% of all the money these scammers made. A tiny group fueled the jackpot.

Lena: $1,771? That’s not pocket change. That’s rent, groceries, savings—gone.

Max: And here’s the kicker: the more they paid, the faster the next scam came. The first time someone sent money, the second hit averaged 201 days later. But for those scammed over 20 times? That gap shrank to just 20 days.

Lena: 20 days? They’re barely catching their breath before the next one!

Max: Yep. Psychic scams took a bit longer between hits—about 60 days more than sweepstakes—but the pattern held: the deeper you’re in, the quicker they strike again. It’s like these scammers smelled blood in the water.

Lena: That’s predatory. Do they ever stop?

Max: Not really. One more twist: March was their peak month—17% higher than the average. October to December? The low season, with November dipping 11% below average.

Lena: March? Why March? Tax season or something?

Max: Maybe. Or people were saving cash for the holidays later in the year. Whatever the reason, these scammers had a rhythm—and older adults were their beat.

Lena: This is wild, Max. It’s not just a crime—it’s a machine.

Max: That’s the word for it. So what does this all mean? These records, ripped from the scammers’ own hands, show older adults aren’t just targets—they’re the prize. They’re hit more, they lose more, and they keep losing. The question is: who’s stopping this?

Lena: Right now, it doesn’t sound like anyone is.

Max: Not enough. This is The Scammers’ Ledger, Episode 1. Next time, we’ll dig into why these scams work—and what’s being done about it. Subscribe, hit that bell, and tell us in the comments: why do you think older adults are so vulnerable?

Lena: Yeah, drop your theories below. Are they too trusting, or are scammers just that slick? We’ll catch you next time.

Max: See you in the ledger.

What do you think—why are older adults so vulnerable to mail fraud? Leave a comment below the video on YouTube or here on Storymagzine.com. Want more true crime? Subscribe to our YouTube channel https://www.youtube.com/@Storymagzine and stay tuned for Episode 2!

Produced by Storymagzine Studios

Crafted with passion by the team at Storymagzine Studios—bringing you the stories that matter.